A recent federal criminal tax prosecution highlights the serious consequences of using abusive trust arrangements and purported charitable foundations to conceal taxable income. The U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) announced on November 16, 2026, that a former healthcare executive and chiropractor was sentenced to 15 months in federal prison after using an illegal tax shelter to conceal more than $4.1 million in income.
The case illustrates an important principle of federal tax law: Simply transferring assets or income into a trust or charitable foundation does not eliminate federal income tax liability when the taxpayer continues to exercise control over the assets and enjoy their economic benefits.
Former CEO Used Abusive Trusts to Conceal Millions in Income
According to the DOJ, Stuart Bernsen, a chiropractor residing in Puerto Rico and formerly of Westmont, Illinois, was the co-founder and former CEO of a company managing a network of more than 100 chiropractic clinics throughout the United States.
Between 2019 and 2021, Bernsen used a series of abusive trusts and a fraudulent charitable foundation to conceal more than $4.1 million in income, resulting in a federal tax loss exceeding $1.2 million.
The government alleged that Bernsen paid approximately $25,000 to establish the illegal tax shelter, despite warnings from a tax professional and IRS guidance that the arrangement was improper.
The structure was designed to create the appearance that Bernsen had permanently transferred his ownership interests and control over various businesses to trusts or a foundation. In reality, however, he retained control of the assets and continued benefiting from the income they generated.
Personal Expenses Disguised as Trust Administration Costs
One of the most significant aspects of the prosecution involved the use of trust and foundation funds to pay personal expenses.
According to the DOJ, Bernsen diverted income into the trusts and improperly characterized personal expenditures as deductible trust administration expenses.
These expenditures included:
College tuition for his children.
A diamond valued at more than $60,000.
The purchase of a boat.
Real estate acquisitions.
Rental of a luxury villa in St. Barth’s for himself and his family, paid using funds from the purported charitable foundation.
These transactions demonstrated that the taxpayer continued to enjoy the economic benefits of the income supposedly transferred to the trusts and foundation.
The use of trust funds for personal expenses, combined with the taxpayer's continuing control over the underlying assets, undermined the claimed tax treatment of the arrangement.Hi
The case was investigated by IRS Criminal Investigation and prosecuted by the Department of Justice.
Why the IRS Challenges Abusive Trust Arrangements
Trusts are legitimate legal arrangements frequently used for estate planning, asset preservation, business succession, and charitable purposes. However, the IRS scrutinizes arrangements that improperly attempt to shift taxable income away from the person who actually earns or controls it.
Several provisions of the Internal Revenue Code may apply to abusive trust arrangements.
1. Grantor Trust Rules — IRC Sections 671–679
Under the grantor trust rules, a taxpayer who retains certain powers or beneficial interests in a trust may continue to be treated as the owner of its assets for federal income tax purposes.
Consequently, income generated by the trust may remain taxable to the grantor even when legal title is held by a trustee.
2. Assignment of Income Doctrine
A taxpayer generally cannot avoid income tax merely by assigning income to another person or entity while retaining the underlying economic rights or control over the income-producing activity.
3. Disallowance of Personal Expenses — IRC Section 262
Personal, living, and family expenses are generally not deductible for federal income tax purposes.
Transferring funds into a trust does not convert personal expenditures, such as family vacations or jewelry purchases, into legitimate business or trust administration deductions.
4. False Tax Returns — IRC Section 7206(1)
Willfully signing and filing a materially false federal income tax return under penalties of perjury may result in criminal prosecution.
A conviction under Section 7206(1) can carry a maximum prison sentence of three years, together with applicable fines and other consequences.
Can Reliance on a Tax Shelter Promoter Protect a Taxpayer From Criminal Liability?
An especially important fact in this case was that Bernsen purchased the tax shelter despite warnings from a tax professional and IRS guidance concerning the impropriety of the arrangement.
Taxpayers sometimes argue that they relied on accountants, attorneys, or financial advisers when implementing aggressive tax strategies.
Although reasonable, good-faith reliance on competent professional advice may be relevant to whether a taxpayer acted willfully, such reliance is not an automatic defense.
Courts generally examine whether the taxpayer fully disclosed the relevant facts, whether the adviser was competent and independent, and whether the taxpayer genuinely relied on the advice in good faith.
Reliance on a promoter who sells a questionable tax shelter may be particularly difficult to establish when the taxpayer disregards contrary professional warnings or knows that the transactions do not reflect economic reality.
Legitimate Asset Preservation Trusts Versus Abusive Tax Shelters
It is important to distinguish legitimate asset preservation and estate planning arrangements from abusive tax shelters.
Properly established and administered trusts may provide substantial benefits, including asset preservation, succession planning, management of family wealth, and protection of beneficiaries.
However, these arrangements must comply with applicable federal tax laws and accurately reflect the legal rights, responsibilities, and economic relationships among the parties.
A trust established for legitimate asset preservation purposes should not be marketed as a means of eliminating income taxes simply by assigning personal income or business assets to a trust while the taxpayer continues exercising unrestricted control.
The Bernsen prosecution demonstrates that the IRS and DOJ will examine the substance of transactions rather than relying exclusively on the legal documents or labels used by taxpayers.
What Should Taxpayers Do if They Have Participated in an Abusive Trust Arrangement?
Taxpayers who have participated in questionable trust or charitable foundation arrangements should consider obtaining an independent legal review before taking corrective action.
Depending on the circumstances, appropriate steps may include examining prior federal income tax returns, determining whether income was improperly excluded, evaluating the deductibility of claimed expenses, and assessing potential civil or criminal tax exposure.
Where the conduct may have been willful, taxpayers should consult experienced criminal tax counsel regarding available options, including whether the IRS Criminal Investigation Voluntary Disclosure Practice may be appropriate.
Importantly, filing amended returns does not automatically eliminate criminal exposure, and taxpayers should carefully evaluate their legal position before making disclosures to the IRS.
Conclusion: Abusive Tax Shelters Can Result in Criminal Prosecution
The sentencing of Stuart Bernsen serves as a reminder that aggressive tax arrangements involving trusts and charitable foundations can create significant criminal exposure when used to conceal income or deduct personal expenses.
Taxpayers considering complex trust arrangements should obtain independent advice from qualified tax counsel to ensure that their structures serve legitimate business, estate planning, or asset preservation objectives and comply with federal income tax requirements.
The central lesson is clear: A trust can be an effective estate planning and asset preservation vehicle, but it cannot lawfully be used as a disguise for personal income or expenditures.
Marini & Associates, P.A.
IRS Tax Litigation and Criminal Tax Defense
Marini & Associates, P.A. represents taxpayers facing complex federal tax controversies, including IRS audits, challenges to trust arrangements, civil tax fraud penalties, IRS Criminal Investigation matters, and federal tax litigation.
Taxpayers who have participated in questionable tax shelter arrangements or received an IRS examination notice should consider obtaining experienced legal representation before responding to government inquiries.
Source and Legal References
U.S. Department of Justice, Office of Public Affairs, Chiropractor and Former CEO Sentenced for Using Abusive Tax Shelter, November 16, 2026, Press Release No. 26-1362. DOJ Press Release
Internal Revenue Code §§ 671–679 — Grantor Trust Rules.
Internal Revenue Code § 262 — Personal, Living, and Family Expenses.
Internal Revenue Code § 7206(1) — Fraud and False Statements.
Lucas v. Earl, 281 U.S. 111 (1930) — Assignment of Income Doctrine.
United States v. Boyle, 469 U.S. 241 (1985) — Reliance on Professional Advice and Taxpayer Responsibilities.
Cheek v. United States, 498 U.S. 192 (1991) — Willfulness in Federal Criminal Tax Cases.
Legal disclaimer: This article provides general information about federal tax law and does not constitute legal advice. The outcome of any tax controversy depends on its particular facts and circumstances.
IRS Cracks Down on Abusive Trust Tax Shelters: Former CEO Sentenced to Prison for Concealing $4.1 Million in Income
Alternative marketing titles:
Abusive Tax Shelter Lands Former CEO in Prison: IRS Targets Fraudulent Trusts
The $4.1 Million Tax Shelter Mistake: How Abusive Trusts Led to Federal Prison
IRS Warning: Using Trusts to Hide Income Can Lead to Criminal Tax Prosecution
When Asset Protection Becomes Tax Evasion: Former CEO Sentenced for Abusive Trust Scheme
Trusts, Tax Evasion, and Prison: IRS Cracks Down on Illegal Tax Shelters
Recommended: Option 1 for a professional tax litigation blog, or Option 2 for a more attention-grabbing marketing headline.













